I've seen the feedback on this forum and on AB. On that forum some people were saying that the puzzle was too easy. Those same people needed to perform somersaults when a solver new to the Listener pointed out that the puzzle was about right for him.
Until I was gagged on AB, I also pointed out that, for long-time Listener solvers, the puzzle had become a good deal easier. I think this year, out of eight alphabetic puzzles, only one has been anything close to normal standard.
On this forum, I think help will always be given to newer solvers - so wouldn't it be better to have Listeners as they used to be ? What is the point of watering down a puzzle to the extent that many established solvers don't even find it a challenge any more ? Silver salver ? I say melt it down and make a tin one.